Pumpkin Milkshake (+ Easy Recipe)

Jump to Recipe

Smooth, spiced, and perfect for any time of year, a pumpkin milkshake captures the cozy flavors of fall with creamy, cool refreshment. Whether you crave pumpkin spice in the middle of summer or want to liven up an autumn afternoon, this homemade milkshake delivers both comfort and a little indulgence in a glass.

Why Make a Pumpkin Milkshake at Home?

A pumpkin milkshake brings together the best of pumpkin pie and vanilla ice cream in one sweet treat. You control the ingredients, customize the flavors, and, unlike most store-bought shakes, get rich pumpkin taste with real pumpkin pie filling or puree. It’s quicker than baking a pie and satisfies those pumpkin spice cravings fast.

You don’t need fancy equipment or obscure ingredients. Most of what you need is likely already in your kitchen.

Ingredients

This pumpkin milkshake recipe calls for a handful of staples and optional toppings. Each ingredient matters; together, they create a smooth, flavorful, and balanced shake.

Main Ingredients

• Vanilla ice cream – Full-fat, cream-based options blend into a dreamy base. If you’re watching dairy or calories, substitute with plant-based or lower-fat alternatives.
• Milk – Whole milk gives the shake a thick, creamy feel, but any milk (almond, oat, soy) works. Adjust ice cream quantity if needed for consistency.
• Pumpkin pie filling – Offers sweetness and spice. For control over sugar content, use plain pumpkin puree and add your own sweetener and spice.
• Brown sugar – Gives a caramel-like depth. Offer a mildly sweet base for customization.
• Pumpkin pie spice – A ready blend of cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, and clove. If you don’t have a pre-made mix, make your own; see the tips section.
• Whipped cream – The classic finish. Coconut-based whipped cream subs well for vegans.

Optional Mix-ins

• A splash of brewed coffee for a pumpkin latte milkshake.
• A frozen banana for thickness and natural sweetness.
• Flavored creamers (like caramel or hazelnut) in place of milk.

How to Make a Perfect Pumpkin Milkshake

The process is quick. You’ll have a frosty treat in under 10 minutes.

Step-by-Step Directions

• Chill your serving glasses
  Pop 2–3 glasses in the freezer before you start. Cold glasses keep your milkshake thick longer.

• Blend the ingredients
  Add ice cream, milk, pumpkin filling, brown sugar, and pumpkin pie spice to your blender. Blend on high until everything is combined and smooth.

• Taste and adjust
  Give the shake a quick taste. If you want more spice, sweetness, or pumpkin, add a bit more and blend again.

• Serve
  Take the glasses out of the freezer. Pour out the milkshake evenly. Don’t rush—watch the thick, delicious ribbons fill each glass.

• Garnish
  Top with whipped cream and a sprinkle of pie spice or cinnamon. See below for more creative topping ideas.

Customizing Your Shake: Ingredient Swaps & Variations

Pumpkin shakes are endlessly adaptable. Try these ideas for your own twist.

Change Up the Ice Cream

• Chocolate and pumpkin: Use half chocolate ice cream for a richer flavor.
• Butter pecan or caramel: Adds a nutty, caramel undertone.

Go Dairy-Free or Vegan

• Ice cream & milk: Coconut, almond, oat, or soy-based ice creams and milks work well.
• Whipped topping: Use coconut or cashew-based whipped toppings.

Sweeten Naturally

• Maple syrup or honey works for a naturally sweet shake.
• Stevia or other non-nutritive sweeteners keep it low sugar.

Spice Level

• If you prefer subtle spice, reduce the pumpkin pie spice slightly.
• Add extra ginger or clove for a warming kick.

Add-Ins and Mix-Ins

• A splash of cold brew turns this into a pumpkin spice frappe.
• Half a frozen banana thickens and sweetens (especially if using plant milk).

Pro Tips for a Creamy, Full-Flavored Pumpkin Milkshake

A few little adjustments can make your shake even better.

• Slightly melt the ice cream before blending. This ensures a smooth texture.
• If using pumpkin puree (instead of pie filling), you’ll likely need a bit more sugar and spice.
• Start with less milk for a thicker shake. You can always add more.
• Scrape down the sides of the blender if ingredients are sticking.
• Serve immediately. This shake’s best fresh.

Topping Ideas: Dress Up Your Pumpkin Milkshake

Get creative with toppings to make your shake shine. These ideas add flavor and flair:

• Graham cracker crumbs — Sprinkle over the whipped cream for a pie-crust crunch.
• Caramel sauce — Drizzle on top for a pumpkin-caramel treat.
• Mini chocolate chips or chocolate shavings — For a bit of richness.
• Crumbled cookies — Ginger snaps, Biscoff, or shortbread.
• Sprinkles — Simple, festive touch for parties.
• A dash of extra pumpkin pie spice — Beautiful and aromatic.

For an over-the-top dessert shake, add a spoonful of vanilla or pumpkin ice cream on top or balance a miniature slice of pumpkin bread on the rim.

Making Your Own Pumpkin Pie Spice

If you don’t have a pre-made blend, make your own with pantry spices. Mix together:

• 1 tablespoon cinnamon
• 1 teaspoon nutmeg
• 1 teaspoon ginger
• ½ teaspoon cloves

Use about a teaspoon for one milkshake batch. Store leftovers in an airtight jar.

Troubleshooting Common Milkshake Issues

• Too thick? Add a splash more milk, a bit at a time, blending after each addition.
• Too thin? Blend in a little more ice cream or a handful of ice cubes.
• Not sweet/spicy enough? Add more sugar or sprinkle in more spice, blending to combine.

For dietary adjustments, remember to check labels when using non-dairy products to avoid traces of dairy or extra sweeteners.

Healthier Pumpkin Milkshake Options

Lighten things up with a few easy swaps:

• Greek yogurt — Use instead of (or in addition to) ice cream for tang, protein, and creaminess.
• Frozen banana — Thickens, sweetens, and lowers calorie count.
• Reduce sugar — Rely on the natural sweetness of bananas, milk, or non-dairy alternatives.
• Plant-based milks — Choose unsweetened milks to control sugar content.

These swaps make the shake more nutritious while keeping all the fall flavor.

Pumpkin Milkshake FAQ

Can I make this ahead?
Milkshakes are best enjoyed right away, but blend ingredients ahead and store in the freezer for up to an hour. Blend again before serving.

Can I use canned pumpkin instead of pie filling?
Yes, but add sugar and spices to taste.

Does it work without a blender?
A blender is easiest, but you can use a food processor or immersion blender. For manual mixing, soften ingredients thoroughly and whisk vigorously.

Can I double the batch?
Definitely—just keep an eye on blender capacity.

Serving Suggestions

Pumpkin milkshakes pair well with cookies, bars, or simple pound cake. Serve in large glasses with reusable straws. Perfect for movie nights, fall gatherings, or a sweet pick-me-up after work.

Pumpkin milkshakes bring together classic fall flavors and creamy, cool comfort. They’re easy, fast, and endlessly customizable. With a few staple ingredients and a blender, you can enjoy a pumpkin pie-inspired dessert any time you like. Try it once, and it will earn a permanent spot in your recipe rotation.